Turtles All the Way Down: A Heartfelt yet Uneven YA Film

John Green’s young adult worlds are known for their dramatic and expansive nature, often featuring big swings, big emotions, and big mysteries. However, his 2017 novel, Turtles All the Way Down, takes a more inward approach, focusing on the internal struggles of its protagonist, Aza Holmes. Aza, a high schooler, battles obsessive compulsive disorder, which often leaves her crippled by intrusive thoughts and fears.

Aza’s struggles with OCD are deeply relatable

The film adaptation, directed by Hannah Marks, does an impressive job of bringing Aza’s inner turmoil to life. Isabela Merced shines as Aza, convincingly portraying the character’s dual nature: the part that wants to fit in and attend Northwestern University, and the part that’s consumed by fears of bacterial infections.

The film’s plot, which involves a missing billionaire and a $100,000 reward, feels somewhat secondary to Aza’s internal struggles. However, it does provide an interesting backdrop for exploring themes of mental health, identity, and relationships.

Aza’s friendship with Daisy is a highlight of the film

One of the standout aspects of the film is its portrayal of Aza’s relationships. Her friendship with Daisy, played by Cicchino, is particularly well-done, capturing the ups and downs of adolescent friendships with remarkable authenticity.

Aza’s romance with Davis is sweet and tender

The film’s romantic subplot, which involves Aza and her childhood friend Davis, is also well-handled. The tension between them is palpable, even when they’re not physically together.

Aza’s thought spirals are visually represented in the film

The film’s visuals are striking, with jarring clicks and flashes of microscope slides effectively conveying Aza’s thought spirals. The cinematography is equally impressive, capturing the quiet desperation of Aza’s struggles.

In conclusion, Turtles All the Way Down is a heartfelt, if uneven, YA film that shines when it focuses on Aza’s internal struggles. While the plot may meander at times, the film’s strong performances and thoughtful direction make it a compelling watch.

“The successes are in large part owed to Merced’s sensitive, grounded performance, her open face able to pass amusement, anxiety, self-loathing vitriol, panic attack and relief like quicksand.”

Isabela Merced shines as Aza Holmes