The Joker's Dark Turn: A Box Office Disappointment for 'Folie à Deux'

The new Joker sequel has opened to disappointing box office numbers amidst mixed reviews, leaving audiences questioning the film's mixed genre approach and its financial viability.

_{^{Photo by Rayi Christian Wicaksono on Unsplash}}

The Joker’s Dark Turn: A Box Office Disappointment for “Folie à Deux”

As I sat in the theater, anticipation buzzing in the air, I couldn’t help but feel the weight of expectation for Joker: Folie à Deux. The sequel to Todd Phillips’ groundbreaking Joker (2019) had generated a whirlwind of excitement, seemingly unshakeable from its predecessor’s massive success. Yet, as the end credits rolled this weekend, the mood in the room was far from celebratory.

Joker: Folie à Deux stirs controversy and questions.

The film opened with a disappointing $40 million domestically, falling drastically short of the projected $70 million, and a far cry from the astounding $96.2 million debut of the original film. With Joker: Folie à Deux topping the box office, the reality sunk in: a muted reception awaited this highly-anticipated sequel, which leaves audiences and critics scratching their heads.

Critical Reception: A Mixed Bag

Initially, Folie à Deux premiered to a 12-minute standing ovation at the Venice Film Festival, generating buzz and excitement. However, this glow quickly faded as the film’s Rotten Tomatoes score plummeted from 63% to a meager 33%. Audiences were less forgiving, encapsulated perfectly when they gave it a dismal D CinemaScore. It seems that not everyone is on board with this venture into Arthur Fleck’s world of darkness.

As Paul Dergarabedian, a senior media analyst, pointed out, “That’s a double whammy that’s very difficult to recover from.” The disappointment hits harder when you consider the hefty budget of $190 million claimed by some estimates. For a film that spends so much and generates such little return, questions are surely going to rise in production offices everywhere.

The Sequel’s Unique Direction

What sets this sequel apart, aside from its financially concerning debut? To start, Folie à Deux veers into the territory of a musical with Lady Gaga joining the cast as Joaquin Phoenix’s character’s superfan. The dreamlike sequences filled with elaborate musical numbers were meant to enchant but instead have perplexed long-time fans who might not have been expecting such a tonal shift.

Jake Coyle from the Associated Press remarked that “Phillips has followed his very antihero take on the Joker with a very anti-sequel.” A film that blends genres—prison drama, courthouse thriller, and musical—can be seen simultaneously as bold and bewildering, leaving many to ponder if the creative risks taken resonate with their audience.

Historical Context: The Weight of Expectations

Comparing this sequel with its predecessor showcases the challenges faced when following up a cultural phenomenon. The original Joker garnered critical acclaim, earning 11 Oscar nominations, including Best Picture and Best Director, while pulling in over $1 billion globally. It became the highest-grossing R-rated film of all time—until recently surpassed by Deadpool & Wolverine, of course.

In light of this legacy, it’s no wonder Phillips aims “to make something as audacious.” But perhaps that ambition backfired; the script could alienate the very fans who propelled the first name into stardom. As Dergarabedian astutely observed, “audiences in 2024 seem to want to know what they’re getting when they’re going to the theater.” In this era, where surprises abound in marketing, predictability often prevails in cinema.

A Community Divided

Despite electoral critiques, there are defenders stepping up to the plate. Legendary filmmaker Francis Ford Coppola vocalized his admiration for Phillips’ works, even amidst his own film’s underwhelming performance at the box office. This reflects a broader debate in entertainment about artistic integrity versus audience expectation—a discourse that continues to challenge filmmakers today.

As the dust settles on opening weekend, we can’t help but wonder what’s next for Folie à Deux and for the cinematic landscape. Japan and China await the film in coming weeks, and opinions around the world will shape its eventual fate. Will the Joker embrace redemption with a musical twist, or does the audience tick-tock closer to silence?

Conclusion: Navigating Cinema’s Future

As we reflect on this cinematic rollercoaster, one thing is certain: Joker: Folie à Deux left us with more questions than answers. Can it reinvent itself and resonate with audiences at large? Or will it remain a stark lesson about creative risks in cinema? Either way, you can bet I’ll be following this unfolding saga closely.

The world of film can be unpredictable, much like Arthur Fleck himself—a haunting reminder that while some stories continue to enchant, others might just fade into obscurity.

Estimated ticket sales for Friday through Sunday at U.S. and Canadian theaters include: